A reader shares her thoughts on the bull terrier case:
Wishing you a very Happy Mothers Day. Your work in helping animals through AnimalCare is akin Mother Theresa helping the destitute and unwanted in the slums of India. You are the Mother Theresa to abandoned and unwanted animals. Another note; Baggy is your Mothers Day gift. She is truly blessed to be a part of your family. I always pray and wishes that she will be in a good home. Wishes do come true!
Bless you for taking in Yoshee into your safe haven. I was worried too as the shelter manager is right there might be a ‘doghunt’ in view of the bull terrier and the unfortunate elderly jogger incident.
Did you read the ‘The star says today’ – the opinion expressed is very menacing for the well being of the bull terrier in question. I fear for his life after reading it – it was so negative, do not know why paper that carry a great influence are so bias without doing in-depth investigations on what really happened that day. It is like instigating public that the dog in question must be penalised severly.
My hubby while jogging in our neighbourhood had a big dog jumped on him from an open gate several weeks ago. He calmly pat down the dog and the dog did not become aggressive but playful. His owner wanted to hit the dog – he told the owner please do not hit the dog as it is not the way to discipline the dog. The dog got excited when he sees someone running and bolted out its premises; maybe it needs the exercise as dogs need to be taken for walks to work off its excess energies or simply bored. Sticks will not help but your inner calm self and confidence is key when faced situation like this.
Hubby reaction towards the dog decide the outcome of the situation; if starts to panic and aggressive towards the dog the dog may be provoked to be aggressive – dogs not usually attack without being provoked or constantly taunted.
My previous neighbour had a lovely and friendly puppy and many times we caught young boys out of nowhere poking him with a stick from outside his gate. Whilst poking the puppy saying things like ‘it’s dirty and bad’. Hubby reprimanded the boys whom we believed are taught and brought up to behave in such manner toward any dogs. Sad this kind upbringing is widespread.
Yes, the rottweiler case; witnesses do attested that the lady taunted the poor dog often that when the opportunity present itself (open gate) he attacked her. Even human will retaliate if taunted that way. This happened in the neighbourhood where my mum-in-law used to live. Sad case of human ‘failures’ that cost an innocent animal life. Hope it will not be the case this time.
It is truly a dog’s life. In front of our home there is a stretch of greens with bamboo trees – many dogs’ owner take their dogs for walk there. There is even one young girl who takes her three big dogs at odd hours of the night – sometimes at 3.00 am – maybe trying to avoid running into any humans who disapprove of dogs. We often heard her screaming at her dogs to wait up for her – we usually sit by our bedroom window and to make sure she is safe until she heads home. There should be dog parks for owners to take their dogs for walk safely and freely without any trouble. Every housing areas should have one. Wishful thinking..
From what I’ve learnt, dogs attack for several reasons:
1. When they are provoked.
2. When they sense fear in us. Hence, I always tell people that if they have even the slightest fear, do not approach the animal. Fear is a negative emotion, and when the dog (or any animal) senses it, it might attack the fearful person. My old dog, Bobby, has a tendency to bark fiercely only at certain people. I think these people have a fear of dogs in them. In other people, even first-time visitors, he would jump up and sit right next to the person on the sofa, as though he is an old friend. Why the difference in behaviour? I think it’s the vibrations given out by each individual.
3. Dogs also attack out of jealousy, and a dog handler confirmed this.
I remember the only time I was ever bitten by a petdog was when I was in my friend’s house. She has a very possessive female dog, named Happy. Happy was alright with me until the time we rescued the Chelsea and the football puppies (http://animalcare.my/2009/10/18/chelsea-and-her-football-team-day-2/) from Bentong and my friend consented to fostering them. Happy got very jealous as my friend’s attention was now divided as she had to look after Chelsea (a female dog) and her puppies. Happy, as smart as she was, must have “blamed” me for bringing in Chelsea and her puppies because I was the one who brought Chelsea and family to the house and whenever I visited, attention was given to this family. Ever since then, Happy would bark angrily each time I even passed the house. One day, long after that, when I visited, Happy came quietly from behind and bit my calf! Then, she walked away. It was blue-black for many weeks, but no tetanus shot was required!
Apart from this incident, I had never been bitten by any dog so far, not even during the few bigtime rescues we made at the Puchong Pound and Klang Pound where the dogs were frothing at the mouth and ferocious at the pound workers. We took the dogs out without any problem, barehanded. No gloves, no leash. We carried them out. Truth be told, we went unprepared because both rescues were last minute operations.
All said, I cannot say I fully and completely understand the mentality of any animal. We would just have to learn more, ask the experts and have pure intentions in our hearts when handling any animal. If we have any negative emotion in us, it is best not to approach the animal. Their sixth sense is very strong and accurate.
This article from today’s NST might shed some light on the incident and might be useful for us to learn more about the behaviour of dogs: http://www.nst.com.my/nation/general/sunday-interview-you-can-stare-down-killer-dogs-1.83216

Comments
16 responses to “Thoughts on the bull terrier case (from a reader)”
I like the interview. Both the trainers give very good insights and explanations on dog behaviour and psychology. I fully agree that all dogs, regardless of size and breed, need exercises to drain energy, and dogs are migratory animals. They need to go out with their pack leader, walk, and come back. This is one of their basic needs. Sadly many don’t understand that. I’ve heard so many people saying ‘I have a compound so my dogs can run there’. I look at their dogs, and it’s always very obvious that they have too much frustration and energy stored in them. And yet the owners always complain that the dogs ‘make noises’, ‘always fight’, ‘always bark at people’, ‘always dig up my garden’, etc BUT refuse to bring them out for walks. Give your dog a purpose, a direction, and fulfill their needs. They will thank you for that and give you less of all of those troubles.
Humans would give their best for their human children…When it comes to their pets, why does most only do enough?? Just because the animal is a different species from a human child, does it mean that it deserves less? If you have taken him/her into your home, you should treat it no different than how you would treat your child, for like your child, he/she is also dependent on you.
When a human kills another, he can plead insanity, but when an animal kills a human, humans automatically pass the guilty verdict. Wait till karma comes along…
There is a saying, I think is from Confuscious. Althought is it about human being, but I think it applies to any life — the beginning of a life is kind — it goes the same as we understand in psychology — nature and nurture.
As I have spent many years living in Europe and the US, I have learned to understand why dogs in Malaysia are fierce. OR why we are afraid of dogs in Malaysia (I am using Malaysia just to keep things simple. NOT bad mouthing Malaysia or Malaysian). When a dog is raised with the intention to use as guard-dog, the dog is trained to bite and kill and bark. The dog is not trained to be just a nice dog. So how can we blamed the dog?
The same in the western world. There were/are cases of dogs killed babies, children. Very often, eventually, the root caused of agression of the dog pointed to the owners.
It is the same with children. There are well behaved kids, and there are rotten kids. Why? Often time one can traced back to parenthood.
Furthermore, in many Asian countries dog = food. So how much compassion or respect people have for dogs or any form of animals in these countries? Often time they do not see animals as a living thing. But ‘thing’ that serves their needs whatever that might be — food, guard-dog, toy, something to kick about …
In Malaysia, we have an added problem. Government officials are given the green-light to come out and shoot and kill strayed dogs (I do not know the name of the department) .. so what kind of example the Malaysian government is giving to certain sector of the society i.e people who hates dogs ??? Encouragement.
IMHO, in Malaysia the dog-hating goes far beyond just some bad-hearted people, it goes deeper into the behaviour of the people in power, i.e the government, and their policies. Change has to take place from the top. A government of a country is like parents to a child. Children learn from the behaviour of their parents.
Mother Teresa is a saint whom nobody is able to match.
She is humble and simple, not care about publicity in
What she does.
Btw, Baloo died of negligence, the pair should not be housed
In a office in the first place.
I hope rehoming should be done in a more stringent manner
In future.
What stringent manner? They needed a home and at that point it must have seemed like the best situation for all. No one can predict the future. Can you? What would you have done different? How many animals have you personally rehomed? Talk is cheap.
Dear I Glum,
First of all, I do not control what readers write, and as per our policy, if we share any write-up from our readers, we publish it verbatim. The only thing we would delete are names of vets and their clinics.
The blog posts about what we do, who we subsidise, who we help, is necessary as accountability to our donors, so that they know where their donations are going to. Our donors are often strangers, and the only way to give them an account of how the donations are spent, is to publish each case on this blog.
One may view the blog posts as “publicity”, but our intention to publicise is for accountability to our donors.
In anything that we or I do, surely there will be many others who can do much better. Unfortunately, when I appealed for help on Baloo and Baggy’s rehoming, no one offered to help.
My offer was only to foster over the weekend, but it ended up as fostering for weeks because the rescuer could not take the kittens back.
When I publicised daily for adopters, nobody offered to take them. My own cat, Indy, was running further and further away from home each day, due to jealousy. I could very well have lost him totally had Baloo and Baggy stayed on with me. Indy, if you do not know, is a kidney-problem suspect and had a very bad start in life. He would not have done very well living as a stray. Baloo and Baggy’s rescuer did not want to take them back because she said she had an allergy problem.
Andy Lew was the only person who offered to take in Baloo and Baggy and if you had followed the blog posts, the kittens were well-looked after in the office. The office may not have been the ideal place, but neither would have any home been, for that matter.
I can only do as much as I can and I hope readers like you would try to understand that we all have our limitations.
As I’ve said, for everything that I do, many others can definitely do better. The only problem is, they did not offer to help out or give suggestions when I was publicly seeking help, and now that an accident has happened, it is easy to point fingers and criticise.
Thank you for your views.
Dear I Glum,
I am the reader who wrote to Dr. Chan of which she posted on her blog.
I sincerely apologize if I have offended you by making the reference to Mother Theresa. It was an error of judgment of my part.
What I was trying to say is is that her work is ‘akin’ or similar in character on the challenges that Mother Theresa faced on changing mindsets. Not in any way I was referring to as Dr. Chan is Mother Theresa in nature.
I regret this misunderstanding; I shall be more mindful in future.
Thank you for pointing out my error.
Thank you.
Apoligize for the typing error ,
The email link is:Ivylam46@gmail.com
Sincerely,
Ivy.
Dear I Glum, nearly everyone who rescues and tries to re-home stray or orphaned animals makes his or her best effort to find a great home for them. There is no such thing as a perfect home! Cats are especially curious creatures — they nibble on things they shouldn’t, they try to escape and explore outdoors, etc. Dr. Chan has never written boastfully about her successful efforts, and she has the courage to write about those efforts that don’t work out well in the hope that others might learn. I don’t believe for a minute that Baggy and Baloo were irresponsibly placed or that the screening was inadequate. I’m sorry you’re Glum, but your criticism in this case is unjustified.
Dear Glum @ Ivy,
1st of all, nobody owes you an explanation. Everyone deserves to have their own opinion. Further, what AnimalCare does need to be publicised in other to create awareness to the public regarding caring to the animal; it is not for personal gain.
Negligent you say? What conclusive evidence that you have to what happen to Baloo? If you follow the earlier blogs, beyond doubt, every steps that AnimalCare did back then in rehoming the blueys with Andy & Emily was done with care and due diligence.
It is easy to criticise and find whom to be blamed so you can be at peace to every misfortunes that happens. But, what justice did you achieve?
Balloo has gone, no one to be blamed for her sudden dismiss. Let her soul rest in peace.
I glum, can you be less rude please? Thanks. Look at how everyone else writes and comments. If all you wanna do is be a big-mouthed rubber-necking armchair commenter then the least you can do is offer suggestions in a more constructive way such as what could be done in FUTURE SIMILAR SITUATIONS. It is not about being judgemental or comparing who’s better. In the end
I think we all just want what is best for the animals. Please stop pointing fingers.
Another point to add, if YOU think rehoming could be done in a more stringent manner, kindly offer help next time.
Just my two cents.
I’m sorry but it just irks me to read things like “i hope rehoming could be done in a more stringent manner in future”. Like, who are you to say that? Are you doing the rehoming or are you in charge of how rehoming is done? Ugh.
Mrs. HJP, please keep writing your ideas and opinions because they are useful and valuable. In fact, you have an engaging writing style. There is no need to be apologetic in this case. Many readers can easily see that your reference to Mother Teresa is a metaphorical one. Keep up the good work (and say thanks to your hubby too for being a great guy)
And let me bring everyone back to earth. Let Baloo’s journey to the rainbow bridge not be in vain. She has come to this earth for a purpose. If assuming, she had died eating a poisoned insect, let us all then be very cautious with what our own furkids eat or play with. We should not take things for granted, life especially. As Kah Yein always say, take / live one day at a time. Our days are numbered and death is certain. In all that we do or say, we should do things or say words so that there are no regrets but that you may one day look back and say, I’ve done the best that i could under the circumstances of that time and the choices or decisions I’ve made is done with the best intentions and hopefully possible outcomes. We are not God and neither can we see the future. Let us be thankful that we had lived our lives loving Baloo and seeing her grow up. She could have died then, but she didn’t. She lived to tell us many stories. Let us all now offer our little prayers for her that she may be happy and chasing butterflies at the rainbow bridge. And fellow animal lovers (I’m assuming you are if you are following this Kah Yein’s blog), please, let Baloo go in peace. It’s time to focus on the now … take care of your furkids. You never know when they will cross the rainbow bridge. Live each day with them like it’s their last and you will never have any regrets.
God bless!
XX Joy XX
Dear I Glum,
You are obviously very troubled by what Dr Chan has been reporting in her blog all these years; hence your rather critical and cynical remark in your comment.
I have been following Dr Chan’s blog for several years and I have never regarded her as someone who wants to seek publicity and fame in whatever she does. On the contrary, I feel that her regular articles have educated the public (eg people like me) about compassion and kindness to the animals. I (and I am sure many others too) have her to thank for for teaching me to share this earth with our animal friends. People have become more aware about the need to neuter/spay animals in order to control the population of animals especially the strays and also to be kind and compassionate to them.
On the matter of Baloo’s unexpected death, nobody knows why she died as no autopsy was done to determine the cause of death. And if you had followed Baloo’s and Baggy’s stories right from the beginning, you would have learned that Dr Chan sought for adopters for them for several weeks but nobody came forward to adopt them. And when someone offered to adopt them, Dr Chan went to the office to determine the suitability of the office as a home for the 2 cats. It is hence very unfair of you to blame Baloo’s death on the office environment. Death, though certain, cannot be predicted and it can strike anytime and anywhere – whether in a home, office or external environment.
You may want to learn something about “rejoicing in the work of others” rather passing cynical remarks to shoot down somebody.
Josephine